Goodall won America’s hearts throughout his time on AGT with soulful renditions of “How Am I Supposed to Live Without You,” “Eye of the Tiger,” and “Faithfully.” He was crowned the Season 19 champion on Tuesday night, beating out dog act Rani & Rhythm, who finished as runner-up.

This all mostly stems from a post by Facebook profile Behind the Songs in which they shared video of the performance in question. In addition to posting the video, the page ripped into Pineda’s performance, saying it was bad because of his “bad voice” and “severe vocal failure.”