Personally, we are torn on the idea. McCarthy doesn’t bring a lot of innovation to the table in terms of scheme but one big edge he has over Tomlin is his willingness to let his offensive and defensive coordinators implement their systems rather than run what he wants.

The Dallas Cowboys had to make one of the hardest decisions of Jerry Jones' ownership when they decided not to renew McCarthy's contract before Tuesday's deadline.  This was the right move, regardless of McCarthy's pedigree and success in the NFL-- even in Dallas.

Dallas joins the list of NFL teams in need of a head coach after the team could not come to terms on a new contract with McCarthy.